But I'm a Cheerleader— Full Cast

Natasha Lyonne

as Megan

Clea DuVall

as Graham

Cathy Moriarty

as Mary Brown

RuPaul

as Mike

Melanie Lynskey

as Hilary

Katharine Towne

as Sinead

Katrina Phillips

as Jan

Joel Michaely

as Joel

Douglas Spain

as Andre

Kip Pardue

as Clayton

Dante Basco

as Dolph

Eddie Cibrian

as Rock

Michelle Williams

as Kimberly

Brandt Wille

as Jared

Bud Cort

as Peter