I Married a Witch— Full Cast

Fredric March

as Jonathan / Nathaniel / Samuel / Wallace Wooley

Veronica Lake

as Jennifer

Robert Benchley

as Dr. Dudley White

Susan Hayward

as Estelle Masterson

Cecil Kellaway

as Daniel

Elizabeth Patterson

as Margaret

Robert Warwick

as J. B. Masterson

Georgia Backus

as Older Woman (uncredited)

Charles Bates

as Wooley's Son (uncredited)

Brooks Benedict

as Country Club Guest (uncredited)

Billy Bevan

as Puritan Vendor (uncredited)

Edward Biby

as Spectator at Fire (uncredited)

Marie Blake

as Purity Sykes (uncredited)

Monte Blue

as Doorman (uncredited)

Aldrich Bowker

as Justice of the Peace (uncredited)