Keeping the Faith— Full Cast

Ben Stiller

as Rabbi Jake Schram

Edward Norton

as Father Brian Finn

Jenna Elfman

as Anna Riley

Anne Bancroft

as Ruth Schram

Eli Wallach

as Rabbi Ben Lewis

Ron Rifkin

as Larry Friedman

Miloš Forman

as Father Havel

Holland Taylor

as Bonnie Rose

Lisa Edelstein

as Ali Decker

Brian George

as Paulie Chopra, the Sikh Catholic Muslim with Jewish in-laws who owns an Irish Pub

Rena Sofer

as Rachel Rose

Ken Leung

as Don

Marilyn Cooper

as 'Don't Walk' Lady

Juan Piedrahita

as Omar

Bodhi Elfman

as Howard the Casanova