Sinister Stepsister— Full Cast

Annika Foster

as Carlee Byrne

Tu Morrow

as Ella Mitchell

Jhey Castles

as Lisa Mitchell

Matthew Pohlkamp

as Jeff Mitchell

Johan Gran

as Ryan

Jacob Taylor

as Blake

Dayne Jarrah

as Noah Mitchell

Madison Russ

as Tiffany

Gigi Gustin

as The Real Carlee Byrne

Ari Atken

as Mark Bradshaw

Matthew Garbacz

as Jace