The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry— Full Cast

Kunal Nayyar

as A.J. Fikry

Lucy Hale

as Amy

Christina Hendricks

as Ismay

David Arquette

as Lambiase

Scott Foley

as Daniel

Lauren Stamile

as Leonora

Mia Sinclair Jenness

as Mollie Klock

Chase Ramsey

as Deputy Doug

Nate Richman

as Deputy Dave

Chandey Michaels

as Margaret Loman

Alexander Pobutsky

as Waiter

Jordyn McIntosh

as Maya (age 6)

Keri Safran

as Nicole Evans

Miranda Roldán

as Roise

Jackenson Pierre Olmo Diaz

as Alice Island Resident