You Might Be the Killer— Full Cast

Fran Kranz

as Sam

Alyson Hannigan

as Chuck

Brittany S. Hall

as Imani

Jenna Harvey

as Jamie

Bryan Price

as Steve ('The Kayak King')

Patrick Walker

as Brad

Jack Murillo

as Freddie

Sara Catherine Bellamy

as Drew

Savannah DesOrmeaux

as Nancy

Carol Jean Wells

as Heather

Peter Jaymes Jr.

as Bob

Olivia Jaye Brown

as Carol

Jesse Gallegos

as Ted

Clara Chong

as Alice

Isaiah LaBorde

as The Wood Carver